In could 1996 physicist Alan Sokal released an essay within the trendy educational magazine Social Text. The essay quoted hip theorists like Jacques Lacan, Donna Haraway, and Gilles Deleuze. The prose was once thick with the jargon of poststructuralism. And the purpose the essay attempted to make was once counterintuitive: gravity, Sokal argued, used to be a fiction that society had agreed upon, and technology had to be liberated from its ideological blinders.

When Sokal published within the pages of Lingua Franca that he had written the object as a parody, the tale hit front web page of the New York Times. It trigger a countrywide debate nonetheless raging at the present time: Are students within the humanities trapped in a jargon-ridden Wonderland? Are scientists deluded in pondering their paintings is target? Are literature professors being affected by technological know-how envy? was once Sokal's funny story humorous? used to be the Enlightenment the sort of undesirable factor finally? and is not it a bit of precise that the which means of gravity is contingent upon your cultural perspective?

Collected right here for the 1st time are Sokal's unique essay on "quantum gravity," his essay revealing the hoax, the newspaper articles that broke the tale, and the indignant op-eds, letters, and e mail exchanges sparked via the hoax from intellectuals around the kingdom, together with Stanley Fish, George F. Will, Michael Bérubé, and Katha Pollitt. additionally incorporated are prolonged essays within which a variety of students give some thought to the long term classes of the hoax.

Show description

Quick preview of The Sokal Hoax: The Sham That Shook the Academy PDF

Similar Physics books

Six Ideas That Shaped Physics: Unit C - Conservation Laws Constrain Interactions (2nd Edition)

ISBN: 0072291524
Author: Thomas Moore
Pages: 308 in PDF
Publisher: McGraw-Hill schooling; 2 edition
Date: June four, 2002

SIX principles THAT formed PHYSICS is the twenty first Century's replacement to standard, encyclopedic textbooks. Thomas Moore designed SIX principles to educate scholars: --to follow uncomplicated actual rules to real looking events --to remedy practical difficulties --to unravel contradictions among their preconceptions and the legislation of physics --to arrange the tips of physics into an built-in hierarchy

Light and Video Microscopy

The aim of this ebook is to supply the main entire, easy-to-use, and informative consultant on mild microscopy. mild and Video Microscopy will arrange the reader for the exact interpretation of a picture and realizing of the residing telephone. With the presentation of geometrical optics, it's going to help the reader in knowing photograph formation and lightweight stream in the microscope.

Quantum Mechanics: An Empiricist View (Clarendon Paperbacks)

After introducing the empiricist standpoint in philosophy of technology, and the options and strategies of the semantic method of medical theories, van Fraassen discusses quantum conception in 3 levels. He first examines the query of no matter if and the way empirical phenomena require a non-classical thought, and what kind of idea they require.

A Student's Guide to Einstein's Major Papers

Our knowing of the actual universe underwent a revolution within the early 20th century - evolving from the classical physics of Newton, Galileo, and Maxwell to the trendy physics of relativity and quantum mechanics. The dominant determine during this progressive swap was once Albert Einstein. in one yr, 1905, Einstein produced leap forward works in 3 parts of physics: at the measurement and the results of atoms; at the quantization of the electromagnetic box; and at the certain thought of relativity.

Extra resources for The Sokal Hoax: The Sham That Shook the Academy

Show sample text content

Quine. those references are available in desires of a last concept (Pantheon, 1993), and The Quantum concept of Fields (Cambridge college Press, 1995). there are numerous others whose works i've got chanced on illuminating, together with the historian of technology Peter Galison, the sociologist of technological know-how Harriet Zuckerman, and the philosophers Susan Haack and Bernard Williams. four See desires of a last concept, and ‘‘Night techniques of a Quantum Physicist,’’ Bulletin of the yankee Academy of Arts and Sciences, quantity sixty nine, No. three (December 1995), p. fifty one. five Thomas Kuhn, ‘‘The difficulty with the historic Philosophy of Science,’’ Rothschild unusual Lecture, November 19, 1991 (Department of the heritage of technology, Harvard university, 1992). 6 Jacques Derrida, ‘‘Structure, signal, and Play within the Discourse of the Human Sciences’’ within the Structuralist Controversy, edited by way of R. Macksey and E. Donato (Johns Hopkins collage Press, 1972), p. 247. Sokal’s Hoax 171 PAUL BOGHOSSIAN What the Sokal Hoax should educate Us: The Pernicious outcomes and inner Contradictions of ‘‘Postmodernist’’ Relativism, and chosen responses occasions Literary complement, thirteen December 1996 * within the autumn of 1994, a brand new York college theoretical physicist, Alan Sokal, submitted an essay to Social textual content, the prime magazine within the field of cultural stories. Entitled ‘‘Transgressing the bounds: towards a transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity,’’ it alleged to be a scholarly article in regards to the ‘‘postmodern’’ philosophical and political implications of twentieth-century actual theories. notwithstanding, because the writer himself later printed within the magazine Lingua Franca, his essay used to be simply a farrago of planned solecisms, howlers and non-sequiturs, stitched jointly that allows you to glance stable and to flatter the ideological preconceptions of the editors. After evaluation through five participants of Social textual content ’s editorial board, Sokal’s parody used to be authorised for e-book as a major piece of scholarship. It seemed in April 1996, in a unique double factor of the magazine dedicated to rebutting the cost that cultural-studies opinions of technology are typically riddled with incompetence. Sokal’s hoax is quick buying the prestige of a vintage succès de scandale, with broad press assurance within the usa and to a growing to be quantity in Europe and Latin the USA. within the united states, over twenty public boards dedicated to the subject both have taken position or are scheduled, together with packed periods at Princeton, Duke, the collage of Michigan, and manhattan college. yet what precisely may still it's taken to teach? i think it exhibits 3 vital issues. First, that dubiously coherent relativistic perspectives approximately fact and proof quite have received broad reputation in the modern academy, simply because it has frequently appeared. moment, that this has had exactly the types of pernicious outcomes for criteria of scholarship and highbrow accountability that one may count on it to have. eventually, that neither of the previous claims want reflect a selected perspective, least of all a conservative one.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.12 of 5 – based on 12 votes