By David T. Johnson

Prosecutors have extra keep watch over over existence, liberty, and recognition than any association in Japan. satirically, this proposition elicits common contract yet few critical efforts to discover its reasons, effects, or importance. The irony makes the procuracy a bit just like the climate: each person discusses it yet nobody does something approximately it.

This is the 1st booklet in English to research how Japan's 2000 prosecutors workout their ambitious powers. It paints an empirical caricature of prosecutors at paintings, the contexts within which they examine, cost, and check out situations, and the content material of the choices thereby rendered. for the reason that prosecutors wield massive discretion at each level of the felony strategy, and because felony complaints represent one of many primary symptoms of the nature of a society, this research bargains a window onto Japan. because this ebook is comparative, mainly with the USA, it additionally gives insights into American legislation and society.

The jap approach of justice is largely decided incidentally prosecutors practice their jobs. If justice potential bearing in mind the wishes and situations of person suspects, then prosecutors in Japan needs to obtain larger marks than their American opposite numbers. If justice implies treating like circumstances alike, then the skill of Japan's procuracy to take action is awesome certainly. If justice may still advertise therapeutic, not only punishment, then eastern prosecutors has to be reckoned extra restorative than prosecutors within the usa. And if justice is dependent upon uncovering and clarifying the reality, then readers will realize how primary this maxim is deemed in Japan. In those methods and extra, the japanese manner of justice is uncommonly simply.

Yet this account uncovers severe defects besides. In processing intercourse offenders, for instance, jap prosecutors frequently and disrespect the sentiments of girl sufferers. of their ardour for holding excessive conviction charges, prosecutors sacrifice the pursuits of sufferers who yearn to be heard in open court docket. of their insulation from political and public scrutiny, prosecutors occasionally appear unaccountable to valid authority and impression. And of their zeal to procure the reality via confessions, a few prosecutors plea discount, physician file, and behavior brutal interrogations, all of that are unlawful in Japan.

Japan is some distance from the us. This publication demonstrates that during many issues of legal justice they're diverse worlds.

Show description

Quick preview of The Japanese Way of Justice: Prosecuting Crime in Japan (Studies on Law and Social Control) PDF

Similar Japan books

Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan

Winner of the Pulitzer PrizeIn this groundbreaking biography of the japanese emperor Hirohito, Herbert P. Bix deals the 1st entire, unvarnished examine the enigmatic chief whose sixty-three-year reign ushered Japan into the trendy global. by no means ahead of has the total lifetime of this arguable determine been printed with such readability and vividness.

Japan: Its History and Culture

It is a revision of the lengthy profitable, brief, illustrated cultural historical past of Japan, from its beginnings approximately 3000 BC to the current day, first released in 1970 and continually in use over numerous variants in faculties and universities national. it truly is designed as an easy, detail-rich portrait of a state now not good understood within the West.

Rashomon and Seventeen Other Stories (Penguin Classics)

Considered one of Penguin Classics' most well liked translations—now additionally in our based black backbone dressRyünosuke Akutagawa is certainly one of Japan's best stylists—a modernist grasp whose brief tales are marked through hugely unique imagery, cynicism, good looks and wild humour. "Rashömon"and "In a Bamboo Grove" encouraged Kurosawa's impressive movie and depict a previous within which morality is grew to become the wrong way up, whereas stories resembling "The Nose," "O-Gin" and "Loyalty" paint a wealthy and resourceful photograph of a medieval Japan peopled by means of Shoguns and monks, vagrants and peasants.

Japanese and Other Altaic Languages (History and structure of languages)

Eastern and different Altaic Languages (History and constitution of languages)

Additional info for The Japanese Way of Justice: Prosecuting Crime in Japan (Studies on Law and Social Control)

Show sample text content

If the prosecutor is obliged to settle on his circumstances, it follows that he can decide upon his defendants. . . . [A] prosecutor stands a good likelihood of finding at the least a technical violation of a few act at the a part of nearly a person. . . . it's during this realm—in which the prosecutor alternatives a few individual whom he dislikes or wants to embarrass, or selects a few workforce of unpopular people after which appears for an offense—that the best possibility of abuse of prosecuting energy lies. it really is the following that legislations enforcement turns into own. Robert Jackson, U. S. lawyer basic and ultimate court docket Justice, “The Federal Prosecutor” eastern procurators . . . have significantly higher authority and restraint than has an American prosecuting legal professional. Chalmers Johnson, Conspiracy at Matsukawa ackson and Johnson are correct: American prosecutors have “tremendous discretion,” but the ability of jap prosecutors is much more monstrous. certainly, it truly is difficult to find a nation agency—inside Japan or out—that wields as a lot energy as Japan’s procuracy. Commentators disagree approximately no matter if eastern prosecutors workout their powers for solid or for sick. a few see them as a key to their country’s crime keep watch over successes and as uncommonly in a position to rehabilitate offenders, repair sufferers, and do justice. Others behold obstinate, self-interested, selectively benevolent officials who, desirous to “play God,” have appropriated powers adequately possessed through judges J three 4 creation and used them to weigh down the rights of suspects, offenders, and sufferers. regrettably, there is not any 3rd college of inspiration populated via those who have studied the prosecutors whom others proclaim as achievers or subverters of justice. the aim of this e-book is to attract an empirical caricature of jap prosecutors, the contexts within which they paintings, and the powers they separately and jointly workout. towards that finish, this creation explains and justifies the alternative of prosecutors as a examine topic, describes how I bought proof for my arguments, offers an outline of the legal procedures in Japan and the us, and summarizes the book’s major claims. Why jap Prosecutors? I spent a lot of the 1990s—including 1000 days in Japan—studying jap legal justice. I interested by prosecutors simply because they make some of the most vital judgements approximately who will get what within the jap method of justice, simply because they seem to be a sorely missed learn web site, and since i used to be in a position to achieve intimate entry to their paintings lives. reflect on every one cause in flip. Contradictory Claims Prosecutors in Japan usually are considered as significant actors, either of their ability to regulate crime and of their skill to make simply judgements. Daniel Foote (1992a), for instance, believes “the aim of felony justice in Japan, as in nearly another state, is conserving order,” and asserts that the “benevolent paternalism” of jap felony justice works to manage crime and continue order, basically by means of fighting recidivism during the rehabilitation and reintegration of offenders.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.70 of 5 – based on 4 votes