By Gregory Nagy

Winner, a call amazing educational Book

The "Homeric query" has vexed Classicists for generations. used to be the writer of the Iliad and the Odyssey a unmarried person who created the poems at a specific second in heritage? Or does the identify "Homer" conceal the shaping impression of the epic culture in the course of an extended interval of oral composition and transmission?

In this cutting edge research, Gregory Nagy applies the insights of comparative linguistics and anthropology to supply a brand new historic version for realizing how, while, the place, and why the Iliad and the Odyssey have been eventually preserved as written texts which may be passed down over millennia. His version attracts at the comparative proof supplied by way of dwelling oral epic traditions, within which every one functionality of a track frequently comprises a recomposition of the narrative.

This facts means that the written texts emerged from an evolutionary procedure during which composition, functionality, and diffusion interacted to create the epics we all know because the Iliad and the Odyssey. guaranteed to problem orthodox perspectives and galvanize vigorous debate, Nagy's publication may be crucial interpreting for all scholars of oral traditions.

Show description

Quick preview of Homeric Questions PDF

Best Literature books

The Roman Tales (Library of Lost Books)

A modern number of tales via certainly one of France’s best writers. respected by means of key literary figures together with as Balzac and Mérimée, Stendhal is healthier identified for his novels, yet his shorter works have been simply as strong. during this fresh translation, Susan Ashe brings his maximum Italian tales to the fashionable reader, when staying actual to Stendhal’s variety and brilliance.

Natural Flights of the Human Mind: A Novel

Peter Straker lives in a switched over lighthouse at the Devon coast with an excellent view of the ocean, cats, and no buddies. that is simply the best way he likes it. He speaks to nobody other than in his desires, the place he converses with the various seventy-eight humans he believes he killed approximately a quarter-century past -- notwithstanding he cannot really bear in mind the way it occurred.

The Birth House: A Novel (P.S.)

An arresting portrait of the struggles that ladies confronted for keep watch over in their personal our bodies, The start home is the tale of Dora Rare—the first daughter in 5 generations of Rares. As apprentice to the outspoken Acadian midwife omit Babineau, Dora learns to help the ladies of an remoted Nova Scotian village via infertility, tricky labors, breech births, undesirable pregnancies, and unfulfilling intercourse lives.

The 13th Apostle

3 SOULS. THOUSAND YEARS. ONE fact. a global conspiracy mystery for the hundreds of thousands of fanatics of The Da Vinci Code who have been left thirsting for extra. .. only one guy can crack the code to the most important secret the realm has ever known-if he survives. .. 36AD: Micah - Jesus' pal, relied on confidant, and the thirteenth Apostle - inscribes a message, upon which mankind's destiny may in the future be decided.

Additional info for Homeric Questions

Show sample text content

Thirteen. back, Harris 1989 :46. 14. So M. L. West 1990 :34. An Evolutionary version tion within the context of actual dwelling oral traditions, the place the writing down of any given composition-in-performance in impression removes the performability of that specific composition. by way of this type of transformed dictation thought, additionally, the know-how of writing needs to be invoked not just for the functionality of the Iliad and the Odyssey yet even for the last word composition of those poems, to the level that the textual content is speculated to in achieving its prestige as textual content on the very second that dictation transforms a composition-in-performance right into a script, because it have been. Lord’s unique concept of Homeric dictation doesn't depart room for using the dictated textual content as a mnemonic gadget for destiny performances by means of the singer who dictated it. Lord himself places it this fashion: “Someone may possibly recommend that it [writing] will be a mnemonic gadget, yet this too is unrealistic. The singer has little need of a mnemonic equipment in a fashion of making a song that used to be designed to fill his wishes with out such written aids. ” 15 Following Lord’s reasoning, Raphael Sealey argues that “the singers may not often suppose the slightest legal responsibility to maintain to the written textual content. ” sixteen Sealey is going directly to reject the inspiration of this kind of written textual content, to which he refers as a hypothetical “bardic text”: he argues that, if a composition just like the Iliad have been preserved when it comes to “bardic texts” within the 8th century, then it's going to were preserved “by inferior poets. ” 17 “But audiences could without doubt want larger poets,” he concludes, “and a poem preserved basically in ‘bardic texts’ will be prone to perish for wish of recognition. ” 18 Reflecting at the observations made by means of Albert Lord approximately genuine dictations taken in fieldwork from the South Slavic oral epic traditions,19 Minna Skafte Jensen argues alongside comparable strains: there's no cause to imagine that later performances of the “same” songs [underwent a power from] the dictation by any means differing from the impact exerted by way of different, past performances 15. Lord 1953 [1991:44]. sixteen. Sealey 1957:329. Sealey (at p. 328 n. fifty nine) really cites Lord’s 1953 article offering the “dictation concept. ” 17. Sealey 1957:330. 18. Ibid. 19. Lord, in his advent to Parry, Lord, and Bynum 1974:8–9. 33 H OMERIC Q UESTIONS 34 of the poems. the concept that the traditional oral poet felt the written model to be a particularly very important factor, to be saved afterwards, turns out to me to be culturally anachronistic, expressive of the literate person’s overestimation of the significance of writing. 20 I accept as true with this line of reasoning, at the least so far as it applies to the 8th or 7th century, the interval of Homeric dictation based on the dictation conception as we've seen it formulated thus far. As we are going to locate, even though, attitudes towards the know-how of writing in later sessions could have replaced, in order that a written model, notwithstanding now not unavoidably a dictated model, could certainly during time have become perceived as “a specifically vital factor.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.09 of 5 – based on 23 votes