In Defining truth, Edward Schiappa argues that definitional disputes may be taken care of much less as philosophical questions of “is” and extra as sociopolitical questions of “ought.” rather than asking “What is X?” he advocates that definitions be regarded as proposals for shared wisdom and institutional norms, as in “What should still count number as X in context Y, given our wishes and interests?”


Covering a large scope of argument in rhetorical idea, in addition to in criminal, clinical, medical, and environmental debates, Schiappa exhibits the act of defining to be a really good and realized habit, and as a result one who may be studied and stronger. in accordance with theories that deem discourse to be persuasive, the writer asserts that each one discourse is definitive discourse that contributes to our development of a shared reality.


Defining fact sheds mild on our tools of constructing universal truths via language and argumentation and forces us to think again the contexts, boundaries, and flexibility of our definitions. Hinging on a synthesis of arguments concerning the importance of definitional practices, the ebook is strengthened by means of a sequence of case experiences of debates approximately rape, euthanasia, abortion, and political and environmental matters. those case experiences flooring Schiappa’s ideas in fact and delineate the facility of public discourse inside of criminal contexts. Ranging commonly between disciplines from philosophy and classical philology to constitutional legislations and cognitive psychology, this learn considerably contributes to the scholarship of rhetoric and argumentation, really as they functionality within the realm of public discourse.

Show description

Quick preview of Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning (Rhetorical Philosophy and Theory) PDF

Best Philosophy books

The Second Sophistic (New Surveys in the Classics)

The 'Second Sophistic' is arguably the fastest-growing region in modern classical scholarship. This brief, obtainable account explores a number of the ways that sleek scholarship has approached probably the most impressive literary phenomena of antiquity, the staggering oratorical tradition of the Early Imperial interval.

Definition in Greek Philosophy

Socrates' maximum philosophical contribution was once to have initiated the quest for definitions. In Definition in Greek Philosophy his perspectives on definition are tested, including these of his successors, together with Plato, Aristotle, the Stoics, Galen, the Sceptics and Plotinus. even supposing definition used to be an incredible pre-occupation for lots of Greek philosophers, it has hardly been handled as a separate subject in its personal correct in recent times.

Origins of Objectivity

Tyler Burge offers a considerable, unique learn of what it's for people to symbolize the actual global with the main primitive type of objectivity. through reflecting at the technological know-how of belief and similar mental and organic sciences, he supplies an account of constitutive stipulations for perceiving the actual international, and therefore goals to find origins of representational brain.

The Philosophy of Epictetus

The Stoic thinker Epictetus has been the most influential of old thinkers, either in antiquity itself and nowa days. Theodore Scaltsas and Andrew S. Mason current ten especially written papers which debate Epictetus' concept on a variety of matters, together with ethics, good judgment, theology, and psychology; discover his family to his predecessors (including his philosophical heroes, Socrates and Diogenes the Cynic, in addition to the sooner Stoic tradition); and think about his impression on later thinkers.

Extra info for Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning (Rhetorical Philosophy and Theory)

Show sample text content

Merchandise four is a purple herring within the experience that there are various crimes (including “stranger rape”) which are tricky to turn out; additionally, there were adequate winning prosecutions in states that experience replaced their legislation to disprove the purpose. merchandise five is extremely not going given the stressful reviews linked to rape trials for the accuser and the low fee of good fortune in prosecution of rape. merchandise 6 has been empirically disproved in states during which the legislation were replaced. merchandise 7 confuses marital intercourse with marital rape; privateness rights don't protect violators of legal legislation. 1 I additionally word that goods 1, 2, four, and seven have been rejected as a safeguard of the marital rape exemption by means of the courtroom of Appeals of latest York in humans v. Liberta (474 N. E. second 567), the oft-cited case that declared that state’s spousal exemption unconstitutional. unlike arguments from outcome, definitional arguments opposed to the removal of the marital rape exemption don't concede 60 what's X? the consent definition of rape; that's, they deny the software of the assumption of marital rape. within the 1954 British case of Regina v. Miller, a lady introduced rape and attack fees opposed to her husband (“Rape and Battery” 1954). on the time of the assault, she were separated from her husband for a 12 months and had initiated divorce complaints. The cost of rape was once thrown out in response to the typical legislation conception of implied consent, even if the spouse had lengthy given that left her husband. In protection of the ruling, one commentator urged that forcible sexual activity could be a type of marital ardour: “Forcible rape among single people is the fruits of a wish whose very inception is disapproved; among married people it's a lack of regulate over an explosive yet inspired scenario” (“Rape and Battery” 1954, 725). Such patently sexist considering replicates the reason of a 1905 case that still exonerated the husband’s habit in accordance with the implied consent conception. In Frazier v. country of Texas, the court docket defined a husband’s coercive efforts towards sexual activity together with his estranged spouse as “a really lively” insistence “upon what he believed to be his rights as a husband” (quoted in Augustine 1991, 564). The 1954 commentator quoted formerly additionally notes that resistance would possibly not safely mirror the real needs of the girl, “since a seeming loss of consent will be easily a manifestation of the truth that resistance in the course of initial love-making tremendously raises the sexual excitement of a few girls” (“Rape and Battery” 1954, 728). during the reviews, the writer essentially makes the prescriptive argument that the criminal definition of rape ought no longer contain coerced marital sex: “[R]ape is a class ill-suited to marriage” (725). Even in jurisdictions during which the consent definition of rape has been followed, there was resistance by way of a few to treating all nonconsensual sexual activity as rape. placing new legislation at the books doesn't make sure that all participants liable for implementing these legislation will instantly assimilate the hot definitions and different types.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.60 of 5 – based on 16 votes